Measles has killed 81 people in Samoa so far, mostly children. Meanwhile, like a pack of hyenas laughing maniacally off stage, the anti-vaccination cult is drooling over the harm and sorrow they’ve helped inflict. But let’s throw a couple of referenced facts at some of the mythical claims they’ve made using their social media megaphones.
Anti-vaxxers didn’t cause the epidemic, a weak vaccination program did
Sorry, but antivaxxers didn’t do all this. Everything suggests they had a role, but to say that a poorly immune population developing an epidemic, when exposed to the causative agent, was due to a small vocal anti-vaccination extremist group misses the bigger picture.
Vaccination programs are run by health departments and ministries. They aren’t run by loud voices from overseas or by traditional healers (who are not necessarily against medications) or by those with limited understanding of the science underpinning viruses and vaccines.
World Health Organization (WHO) data show that Samoa’s first dose of measles-containing vaccine (MCV1) was given to well under 80% of eligible people across 11 of the 15 years between 2004 and 2018.
In four of those years levels fell to below 50% and in 2004 and 2018 were below 40%. These are levels that won’t stop measles transmission.
But between 1985 and 2002 – levels of the MCV1 were at 90% or above. So vaccination rates have been problematic for about 15 years but before 2003 they were as good in Samoa as the best nation anywhere. Something changed that might be worth dwelling on.
What about the second dose (MCV2) of the measles vaccination course? This seemed to come into routine use in Samoa from around 2006 after which it only reached higher than 80% of the eligible population once during those 13 years.
Painfully apparent is the specific plummet in 2018 of either dose. This was influenced by the deaths of two infants following a human error during the preparation of a measles-containing vaccine. A vial of muscle relaxant was used instead of one of water to prepare the injection.[6,7,8] However, rates were already low. This epidemic can’t be pinned on any one event or dose of antivaxxer poison. This is a bigger and much more complex failure.
On a side note, the pattern of low vaccination rates among the people on Samoa also extends to expatriate Samoan communities.[3,5]
So unless there are old links between antivaxxers and Samoa’s government that have influenced its vaccination decisions over a number of years, this epidemic is not caused by antivaxxers. It’s more likely caused by the interplay of a complex host of barriers to and influences on vaccine uptake which may include…
- Past experiences with vaccination
- Cultural norms
- Family structure
- Language barriers (moreso among ex-pats [3])
- Low health literacy about certain diseases, transmission, viruses, bacteria, and the importance of vaccines
- A functional vaccination record/reminder system
- Ease of availability of vaccines
- Increased training of health workers to update knowledge, skills and interpersonal communication
- Provision of cold chain supplies and training in its use and need
- Poorly communicated incentive programs
- Not making it clear that vaccination can complement traditional medicine
- Too little support for vaccination from public figures and Government
- Insufficient funding for all of that to be made possible, forever
These issues are examined in more depth elsewhere.[3,4,11]
Measles infection can’t be prevented using vitamins.
Wouldn’t that be great if vitamins were an easy fix? And wouldn’t we all be so healthy because of all the vitamins we’d swallow? But they don’t work in this way.
Source: Government of Samoa Facebook page [30]
There is no scientific evidence I’m aware of to show that vitamins alone can prevent measles virus from infecting our cells. And there is none which shows the use of vitamins prevent uncomplicated measles disease either.
Apparently there’s also no clear evidence for vitamin A deficiency among cases in Samoa, despite the cries of malnutrition and poor sanitation from anti-vaxxer outsiders.[31]
“We’re not really seeing evidence of acute malnutrition,” says the British paediatrician Dr Owens, who arrived from the UK on the same flight as me. “As I understand it, there is very little evidence of clinical vitamin A deficiency. And I’ve not met a patient yet with a defined immune deficiency.”
A review of other scientific studies actually found that vitamin A has no effect on preventing lower respiratory tract infection and even found some studies that suggested its use made things worse.[14]
Vitamin A is useful for preventing measles death
However, vitamin A is known – in high and multiple doses – to reduce deaths and pneumonia in those already infected by measles virus, even if they are well-nourished.[12,13,14,20] That’s why it was rushed to Samoa in the early stages of the outbreak.
Vitamin C is not going to prevent anything
Vitamin C is important for life but its curative and preventative effects on virus infections are mostly driven by old thinking, myths and profit.[17,18] Vitamin C is readily available in diets that have some fruit and vegetables in them.
There just isn’t any solid evidence that its use prevents infection. It may have a role in shortening symptoms [16] due to infection by some viruses but only by an insignificantly small amount.[18] And importantly for measles in Samoa, it seems that in the absence of a vitamin deficiency, the evidence isn’t strong that its use can prevent serious disease.[15,19]
You can see then how incredibly unlikely
The only current way to prevent infection is with a previously exposed immune system which is primed and ready to fight any new infection. The safest and easiest way to prime that immune response is through
Photo by Wilson Stratton on Unsplash
Measles isn’t spread by poor sanitation, it’s spread by infected droplets
Some still have to roll out their paternalistic, probably racist and colonialist opinions that nations which don’t live in concrete and glass canyons will, of course, have measles because of poor sanitation. Measles spreads largely by droplets expelled from an infected and highly infectious person. These droplets land on surfaces and spread through the air. They also do this in the aforementioned utopian cities…when immunisation rates are low.
Improved sanitation reduces all-cause mortality, but not specifically the measles virus. Measles vaccination reduces measles.
The Samoan epidemic didn’t start once vaccination commenced
This anti-vaxxer theory is just simple ignorance. The first case (an infected traveller from New Zealand [28]) visited and left Samoa by August 19, 2019. The next cases were brewing in September and were laboratory confimred from samples sent to a laboratory in Australia in late September and more in early October. UNICEF started sending the first of its 115,500 doses of MCV vaccine and 30,000 vitamin A pills on October 1, 2019.[21]
Approximately 33,000 people had been vaccinated up to November 20,[22] after when a mass measles vaccination campaign began in earnest and culminated with December 5 and 6 government shut-down to complete a door-to-door vaccination campaign across Samoa.
Vaccination didn’t begin until after cases emerged. As is the usual reactive approach to things like this.
Measles cases actually peaked in the week of the door-to-door campaign.
Vaccine and epidemic viruses are genetically different
Another fanciful anti-vaxxer theory follows on from the last one. It ludicrously posits that the vaccine virus is causing disease in Samoa. Apart from the outbreak being underway before vaccination started, there is another big spanner in this wheel.
The vaccine uses a weakened measles virus that belongs to genotype A. Genotype A viruses don’t circulate naturally anywhere in the world today because they don’t transmit and cause measles. Genotype A measles vaccine virus genetic material can be detected for a time after vaccination, but the transmission of vaccine virus has not been documented.[23]
Why ludicrous? Because the MeV driving the epidemic in Samoa is a virus of genotype D8.[24] This is a genetically different virus.
Sure, not every sample was genotyped, but enough were at the outset of the epidemic. Once you know that you have an ongoing epidemic of a clinically distinguishable disease on your hands, and you know the initial viral cause, you’re set.
While it is possible that another genotype dropped in partway through the epidemic, it’s unlikely. But it can happen; New Zealand’s epidemic is an example in which D8 and B3 genotypes were co-circulating). Still, that doesn’t change patient management, there is only need for a single vaccine, and it still isn’t going to have anything to do with vaccine virus.
So this one is easily disproved as wrong.
Measles is not just a mild disease
Your experience may have been that you had measles…most likely quite some years ago (thanks vaccines)…and you were fine. From this, you think everyone should have your experience?
Chances are, in a room full of people, there will be some who die tomorrow; they kill themselves, die of a heart attack, are poisoned, get run over, crash their car, get shot to death…and so on. Does this mean that mental health, heart disease, cars and guns are not dangerous just because none of these things happened to you? Of course not!
Measles virus is a debilitating and deadly virus. Not all the time. Not even most of the time. But enough of the time that it warrants the development of a safer preventative medicine; a vaccine.
Symptomatic measles infections usually don’t cause death, or hospitalisation, or encephalitis, convulsions, deafness, intellectual disability, pneumonia, premature birth, low-birth-weight babies SSPE Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). But it does sometimes. Perhaps more often than you think.[1]
Have a look at New Zealand (above) and Samoa.
Measles has caused high rates of hospitalisation among children and adults in New Zealand. It has killed children and adults. Open your eyes and look at the reality of this. Most of these have been in unvaccinated people – and nothing else has helped them.
Source: [27]
Why didn’t measles cause more cases and deaths in the parallel ongoing outbreaks in Tonga (596 cases, 15 hospitalisation and zero deaths [25]) and Fiji (25 cases, zero deaths [26])? Perhaps because they have higher rates of vaccination than Samoa.
Facts still matter to people – if they can find them
None of the anti-vaxxer arguments have held up to even the slightest of scrutiny during the tragedy of the Samoa measles epidemic.
While that lack of robust logic won’t surprise anyone who has engaged them, it might surprise those who are still a bit unsure about vaccination because the cult makes a lot of noise and sound very sure of themselves.
Keep communicating realities in ways that the public can understand them. That’s where all the hot air may actually be of some use. We currently waste too much of it on each other.
References…
- Complications of Measles
https://www.cdc.gov/measles/symptoms/complications.html - Measles rash photo from Public Health Image Library (PHIL), Centers for disease control and prevention (CDC)DC
https://phil.cdc.gov/Details.aspx?pid=1151 - The health of Queensland’s Samoan population 2009
https://www.health.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0026/388430/health-data-samoan.pdf - CDC Goes to Samoa to Battle Measles & U.S. Anti-Vax Disinfo
https://www.thedailybeast.com/cdc-goes-to-samoa-to-battle-measles-and-us-anti-vax-disinfo - Responding to a measles outbreak in a Pacific island community in western Sydney: community interviews led to church-based immunization clinics
https://ojs.wpro.who.int/ojs/index.php/wpsar/article/view/277/461 - Samoan nurses jailed over deaths of two babies who were given incorrectly mixed vaccines
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-08-02/samoa-nurses-sentenced-manslaughter-infant-vaccination-deaths/11378494 - How a wrong injection helped cause Samoa’s measles epidemic
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-50625680 - Infant deaths in Samoa a tragic outcome from error preparing MMR vaccine
https://www.immune.org.nz/hot-topic/infant-deaths-samoa-tragic-outcome-error-preparing-mmr-vaccine - https://www.who.int/immunization/monitoring_surveillance/data/wsm.pdf
- WHO vaccine-preventable diseases: monitoring system. 2019 global summary | Coverage time series for Samoa (WSM)
http://apps.who.int/immunization_monitoring/globalsummary/coverages?c=WSM - Government of Samoa, National Measles Response and Recovery Plan
https://reliefweb.int/report/samoa/national-measles-response-and-recovery-appeal-6-december-2019?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shared&utm_source=facebook.com&fbclid=IwAR2YCWf-u_gNHApQlkOvYdUi1yIDcQcZPTj7C15Da5apw8p_NAF8-A8gpMg - A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Vitamin A in Children with Severe Measles
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199007193230304 - Vitamin A Treatment of Measles | Committee on Infectious Diseases
https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/91/5/1014 - Vitamin A for treating measles in children
https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD001479/full - Mythbusters: Does Vitamin C Really Help?
http://www.yalescientific.org/2015/03/mythbusters-does-vitamin-c-really-help/ - Vitamin C and Infections
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5409678/ - How Linus Pauling duped America into believing vitamin C cures colds
https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7547741/vitamin-c-myth-pauling - Vitamin C for preventing and treating the common cold
https://www.cochrane.org/CD000980/ARI_vitamin-c-for-preventing-and-treating-the-common-cold - Vitamin C for preventing and treating pneumonia
https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD005532.pub3/full - Measles
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(17)31463-0/fulltext - UNICEF delivers over 260,000 vaccines and medical supplies to fight measles outbreaks in Samoa, Fiji and Tonga
https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/unicef-delivers-over-260000-vaccines-and-medical-supplies-fight-measles-outbreaks - (PRESS RELEASE 11) November 27, 2019
https://www.facebook.com/samoagovt/photos/a.900118486685841/2777759758921695/?type=3&theater - A Systematic Review of Human-To-Human Transmission of Measles Vaccine Virus
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27083423-a-systematic-review-of-human-to-human-transmission-of-measles-vaccine-virus/ - WHO/UNICEF SECRETARIAT SUPPORTING MEASLES OUTBREAK PREPAREDNESS AND RESPONSE IN THE PACIFIC
https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/wpro—documents/dps/outbreaks-and-emergencies/measles-2019/measles-pacific-sitrep-20191122-docx.pdf?sfvrsn=d8166638_2 - https://reliefweb.int/report/tonga/tonga-measles-outbreak-2019-situation-report-11
- https://reliefweb.int/report/fiji/media-release-18-measles-26-dec-2019
- Measles weekly report, Institute of Environmental Science and Research Ltd (ESR) and Ministry of Health, New Zealand Week 51: 14–20 December 2019
https://surv.esr.cri.nz/surveillance/WeeklyMeaslesRpt.php?we_objectID=5066 - Measles alert for passengers on flight from Samoa to NZ [thanks JL]
https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/397791/measles-alert-for-passengers-on-flight-from-samoa-to-nz - Government of Samoa, Facebook page, NATIONAL EMERGENCY OPERATION CENTRE: (PRESS RELEASE 43) December 29, 2019 https://www.facebook.com/samoagovt/posts/2851440981553572
- Press Release: AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL ASSISTANT TEAMS
https://www.facebook.com/samoagovt/posts/2831747036856300?__xts__[0]=68.ARC6y9qjDRicwYZqOJL3M8NZvuUpVJmDrqnr7x4Zuhx-bZkJQr124DSXqAjlIlK-ASxToWXQ3WFCqChPGT89Ps6yA4JxKkG6u2860M9jG3AJVCyUwNj7_bcKQ9pWcQu90s-xTDczIAPW2d6J6XMmXoVg0J-vKuINnXJrVKOQl3_PeveDHKNKmMYZSTlhH7xkO6DrHSVkAcxgf6c7iUY3faY1LnMM_ORfSS28Gix9zPon9EuUAoMjilrmAp7hU9BQk_6BK8WBImXsy8OQQSchBjRSW_2xxC0rqI2vmLJeA4yfnEK8XHdF89n_NNO3LUIbCn5mINnJI1efxV-b0cuVjL_heg&__tn__=-R - Samoa’s perfect storm | How a collapse in vaccination rates killed more than 70 children
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/measles-in-samoa/
Views: 6542
Informative article easy to understand and follow. Thank you so much for making the time and putting in th effort in writing all of these article. We would love to figure out how to get the info in front of the vaccine hesitate time to let the anti vaxxer go. Save the ones you can
Here’s a paper that demonstrates Vitamin A will combat Measles, a Natural Childhood Illness that we all should acquire for its Short Term & Long Term Health Benefits. Here’s an excerpt;
….”Several recent investigations have indicated that vitamin A treatment of children with measles in developing countries has been associated with reductions in morbidity and mortality. The World Health
Organization (WHO) and the United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF) issued a joint statement recommending that vitamin A be administered to all children diagnosed with measles in communities where vitamin A deficiency (serum vitamin A <10 pg/dL) is a recognized problem and where mortality related to measles"….
https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/91/5/1014.full.pdf
That article does not say what you think it says. It doesn’t say it prevents or combats measles. It says it combats the attendant complications. Which is the same thing THIS article says.