“Look at us, it says, aren’t we clever?”Well yes, actually we are – it’s just that we’re not very good at telling you about it and you don’t really care anyway.[1]

This is the end of a post on the 6,000 miles from civilisation blog I read in August 2016. It nicely wrapped up a spookily familiar-feeling discussion I’d had about the same topic, an earlier piece of writing by Richard P Grant published in the Guardian the day before.[2] Familiar because my wife and I had a very similar discussion about the public not really caring about being communicated to, with or at when it comes to science.
I have a few thoughts on both pieces, far fewer on Grant’s piece because the 6000 piece covered it back then, and I drafted a post about it but never published it. Here it is, with some additions to make it feel contemporary.
First up – we’ve developed the concept of “science communication” into an umbrella term for a lot of things. You may be a science communicator if you “take on” homeopaths or climate change denialists (science advocate), if you break down a piece of science to a lay audience (science interpreter), if you review a science topic as a journalist (science journalist), if you get paid to listen to the public for 20 minutes, self-affirm your position among your peers or if you step outside your “cosy little bubble and make an effort to reach people where they are”. That’s a broad list that doesn’t even drill down into all the different types of basic and applied science, nor whether some science is just too niche or boring to bother communicating at all.
Grant was left cold when Prof Brian Cox brought a graph to a yelling match in a recent TV panel forum.[3] Me too. I loved the graph, and I loved that Prof Cox came prepared, but I knew many wouldn’t see the detail or interpret the graph’s subtleties, which became the focus of a pointless exchange. More importantly, I knew it didn’t answer the Senator’s question, “show me the empirical evidence”, for climate change. A tricky, trappy question in itself, one scientists are still often unprepared to face or answer satisfactorily. If that question had been dealt with and if Senator Roberts’ repetitive use of “empirical evidence” had been directly addressed (what do you actually want to see?), I think it would have been a much more effective “smackdown”. Instead, we witnessed parallel and unsatisfying exchanges. No smackdown and no win for any sort of communication.
Not all science needs to be communicated
The 6000 miles blog aptly sums up the elephant in the room: “generally the public don’t actually care about science”.
But some science definitely should be communicated to them; public health science and medical science spring to my not-at-all-biased mind. But I believe that if we taught science more accessibly, contextually, and interestingly to our kids earlier on, we’d reduce the very obvious issue of science illiteracy. There probably isn’t a “need” to fight to communicate science all the time, but as a now-retired one, I still feel a hell of a lot of scientists need to try their hand. It would be good for some to face people who are academic opposites. There will be mistakes, but will they be any more egregious than those the non-science churnalists produce? No bloody way. If scientists are losing any fight as Grant proposes, it’s more likely because they are poorly equipped and too few in number. Today, producing facts to feed into AI-harvested datasets has never been more important. If probably too late.
The reality is, the people who could benefit from seeing a climate change denialist get smacked down probably didn’t watch the TV panel show. They probably don’t read the good content from good science communicators. Although today, unlike in 2016, it may still be presented to them as part of AI-generated summaries. Just like an antivaxxer (not the fence-sitters or vaccine denialists – I’m talking about the hardcore leaders of anti-vaccination sentiment), I tweeted at that time who didn’t want to engage or discuss anything – just send me links to cleverly put together webpages jam-packed with falsehoods that had been crafted to support an assertion that aluminium adjuvants cause death. These “dangerous ones”, as Grant calls them, won’t be reached whether we spoon-feed, yell, talk calmly or draw them a picture in crayon. They aren’t stupid; they’re as cunningly clever as anyone, but for various reasons, they have their fingers in their ears.
So scientists can get a bit factual: we’re human too, and when someone puts their fingers in their ears, our blood pressure can rise a little. It’s far from a perfect communication style, but it’s authentic! And frankly, we shouldn’t seek perfection here, just reminding everyone that some things are real, and some are lies spread for – often – personal gain.
But the last point is the one from Grant – “That’s not communication. It’s not changing minds, and it’s certainly not winning hearts and minds. It’s tribalism.” Um. Yes. Of course it is. We’re tribal creatures. I’m in the Star Trek tribe, she’s in the Star Wars tribe, and she keeps saying Han shot first. I’m an accountant and can’t, for the life of me, tell you what is happening with your money in any semblance of plain English. I like Rugby; they like soccer, and why is that a ruck and not a maul? Apparently ‘offside’ is explanation-resistant. I’m a bioinformatician and – well, that’s another post entirely (I mean seriously – what world do you guys inhabit?).
We all come from our own tribes and, give or take, we once upon a time could still communicate with each other successfully.
Scientists didn’t lose the communication contest with the public because they all speak their own tribal language; they are failing because they’re not out there anymore. It’s been an abusive and frankly dangerous time for a lot of those scientists, especially over the past six years. I don’t blame them for, if they still have a job, getting back to work instead of sharing their expertise and getting publicly failed, threatened, and abused for it. But we need to look at those scales. They aren’t tipped in reality’s favour. Authoritarian forces have put their boot on their side of the scales, and it’s already hard to know what’s real and what is a lying pile of fake slop. Those who still value science, facts, and reality need to at least boost that signal.
What can you do?
So get out there and make waves in your algorithm! Block lies and slop; amplify reality and facts (don’t just like, repost as well).
Reward good and punish bad. It doesn’t have to be perfect, but it needs to be verifiable. It’s a small, easy thing to do, but every one of us can do that. We know this, because the lying liars, who I firmly believe are the minority, mastered these skills long ago.
References…
- Communicating science
http://6000.co.za/communicating-science/ - Why scientists are losing the fight to communicate science to the public
https://www.theguardian.com/science/occams-corner/2016/aug/23/scientists-losing-science-communication-skeptic-cox - Q&A smackdown: Brian Cox brings graphs to grapple with Malcolm Roberts
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/aug/16/qa-brian-cox-brings-graphs-malcolm-roberts

Discover more from Virology Down Under
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
